Quality does matter. its what you like. whats your taste. if youre the creator and for example its obvious your character crashes the game everytime and you dont want to fix it even though you see it then yeah thats a problem. Its the users choice at the end of the day if they want to continuing giving the creator a chance to see if they will fix the issues in the character. Everybody wants a cool character or stage they would like to keep and not delete. too many other mugen chars to be crying about whats wrong in one.....its pointless
And lets be real here its sh*t load of authors at every site good and bad releasing characters either 25% f*cked up or 90% f*cked up. Its about what crowd is gonna go at whom easy on the problem. I feel if youre on character "success" 3 you should not be still releasing material still screwed up in "basic" coding ares as before as a noob would be doing. Id like to think that BUT thats almost impossible for a perfect release thread with NO BUGS to report. some creators get bashed over it while "popular" ones just get "easy" feedback. No one wants to be that guy to say something harsh at some site to the "Great creator :-@" because hes put out so many cool characters 8=|.....
Prime example. A recent terry bogard character was released.....the projectiles wasnt connecting up close at all and totally missing straight through. I LIKED the character so i wanted to help and showed him a pic and told the creator what was going on. He said well i made it like the source game where it misses up close. JUST because its source doesnt mean its right. CAPCOM had that same issue with older SF2 and they stopped that because it was a bad bug to keep in future games. I tried that crap with my own terry eons before and got eaten alive with flames and FIXED IT. So when this whole quality in mugen stuff comes up i roll my eyes to it now. its no secret the MOB at certain sites attack who they feel like attacking and NOT supporting. FACT....
I gave the man great feedback and he didnt take it. i didnt get mad. for what? i just moved on with my life. do i hate the character NO. Is it quality?? hell no. projectiles that miss up close like that isnt quality to me. its bad gameplay. mugen should be used to create in your vision YES but to also RE create what was in your favorite fighting game MINUS all the flaws it had that we once hated but grew to deal with and took advantage of since there were no fast online patches back then.....
But anyway create for mugen if you enjoy it. if youre serious then at least TRY to learn to get better at it if youre going to release stuff to the public. whether its sprite work or coding. Not all opinions are meant to be listened to either. ITS YOUR IDEAS. But any tip that helps you FIX a major problem should be considered and listened to though. You cant please everyone either.